[python] Fastest way to check if a value exist in a list
As stated by others,
in can be very slow for large lists. Here are some comparisons of the performances for
bisect. Note the time (in second) is in log scale.
Code for testing:
import random import bisect import matplotlib.pyplot as plt import math import time def method_in(a,b,c): start_time = time.time() for i,x in enumerate(a): if x in b: c[i] = 1 return(time.time()-start_time) def method_set_in(a,b,c): start_time = time.time() s = set(b) for i,x in enumerate(a): if x in s: c[i] = 1 return(time.time()-start_time) def method_bisect(a,b,c): start_time = time.time() b.sort() for i,x in enumerate(a): index = bisect.bisect_left(b,x) if index < len(a): if x == b[index]: c[i] = 1 return(time.time()-start_time) def profile(): time_method_in =  time_method_set_in =  time_method_bisect =  Nls = [x for x in range(1000,20000,1000)] for N in Nls: a = [x for x in range(0,N)] random.shuffle(a) b = [x for x in range(0,N)] random.shuffle(b) c = [0 for x in range(0,N)] time_method_in.append(math.log(method_in(a,b,c))) time_method_set_in.append(math.log(method_set_in(a,b,c))) time_method_bisect.append(math.log(method_bisect(a,b,c))) plt.plot(Nls,time_method_in,marker='o',color='r',linestyle='-',label='in') plt.plot(Nls,time_method_set_in,marker='o',color='b',linestyle='-',label='set') plt.plot(Nls,time_method_bisect,marker='o',color='g',linestyle='-',label='bisect') plt.xlabel('list size', fontsize=18) plt.ylabel('log(time)', fontsize=18) plt.legend(loc = 'upper left') plt.show()
I'm searching for the fastest way to know if a value exists in a list (a list with millions of values in it) and what its index is? I know that all values in the list are unique like my example.
The first method I try is (3.8sec in my real code):
a = [4,2,3,1,5,6] if a.count(7) == 1: b=a.index(7) "Do something with variable b"
The second method I try is (2x faster:1.9sec on my real code):
a = [4,2,3,1,5,6] try: b=a.index(7) except ValueError: "Do nothing" else: "Do something with variable b"
Proposed methods from user (2.74sec on my real code):
a = [4,2,3,1,5,6] if 7 in a: a.index(7)
In my real code, first method takes 3.81sec and the second method takes 1.88sec. It's a good improvement but:
I'm a beginner with Python/scripting and I want to know if a fastest way exists to do the same things and save more process time?
More specific explication for my application:
In the API of blender a can access to a list of particles:
particles = [1,2,3,4...etc.]
From there, I can access to its location:
particles[x].location = [x,y,z]
And I test for each particle if a neighbour exists by searching in the location of each particle like:
if [x+1,y,z] in particles.location "find the identity of this neighbour particles in x:the index of the particles array" particles.index([x+1,y,z])
For me it was 0.030s(real), 0.026s(user) and 0.004s(sys).
try: print("Started") x = ["a", "b", "c", "d", "e", "f"] i = 0 while i < len(x): i += 1 if x[i] == "e": print("Found") except IndexError: pass
You could put your items into a
set. Set lookups are very efficient.
s = set(a) if 7 in s: # do stuff
edit In a comment you say that you'd like to get the index of the element. Unfortunately, sets have no notion of element position. An alternative is to pre-sort your list and then use binary search every time you need to find an element.
It sounds like your application might gain advantage from the use of a Bloom Filter data structure.
In short, a bloom filter look-up can tell you very quickly if a value is DEFINITELY NOT present in a set. Otherwise, you can do a slower look-up to get the index of a value that POSSIBLY MIGHT BE in the list. So if your application tends to get the "not found" result much more often then the "found" result, you might see a speed up by adding a Bloom Filter.
For details, Wikipedia provides a good overview of how Bloom Filters work, and a web search for "python bloom filter library" will provide at least a couple useful implementations.
present = False searchItem = 'd' myList = ['a', 'b', 'c', 'd', 'e'] if searchItem in myList: present = True print('present = ', present) else: print('present = ', present)